Matthews R. Bark, P.A.Criminal Defense
The Law Offices of
Matthews R. Bark, P.A.
In November 2026 I spent three days in South Miami Beach at a continuing education program for psychologists and neuropsychologists, "Executive Functions and Dysfunction in Brain Health and Brain Disorders." It was taught by Dr. Elkhonon Goldberg, one of the world's leading authorities on the frontal lobes. I was likely the only criminal defense lawyer in the room.
I went because so many of the people I defend are not who the police report makes them out to be. A charge describes an act. It rarely explains the brain behind the act. More and more of my practice involves clients whose behavior is shaped by a developmental condition, a brain injury, or a dementia that no one has diagnosed yet. To defend those clients well, I need to understand the science as well as the experts who testify about it.
"Executive functions" are the mental abilities that let a person set a goal, plan the steps, stay on task, shift course when things change, control impulses, and foresee consequences. Dr. Goldberg compares the prefrontal cortex to an orchestra conductor or a company's CEO. It does not play any one instrument. It coordinates all of them.
The prefrontal cortex does not do any one job. It directs the abilities that complex decisions depend on.
When that system is damaged or underdeveloped, a person can still talk, remember, and score reasonably well on many tests. What breaks down is judgment: planning, flexibility, impulse control, and insight into how others see them. From the outside, that can look like defiance, dishonesty, or a lack of remorse. In a courtroom, those are exactly the traits that drive charging decisions, bond, and sentencing.
One idea from the course stays with me. Modern neuroscience no longer thinks of the brain as a set of separate parts, each with one job. It thinks in networks. The frontal lobes are connected to nearly every other system in the brain, which is part of why they are so vulnerable to injury, illness, and aging.
The frontal lobes are among the last parts of the brain to mature. By some measures their development runs past age 18, into the late 20s or early 30s. Dr. Goldberg pointed out that these ages roughly track the points at which societies, ancient and modern, grant people adult legal and social responsibility.
Myelin is the insulation on the brain's wiring. Humans start with almost none and finish late. The frontal pathways are the last to be wired.
The point matters for young clients. An 18- or 20-year-old is an adult under the law. The part of the brain that weighs consequences and restrains impulses is often still developing. That does not excuse a crime. It does help explain one, and it belongs in front of a prosecutor deciding what to offer and a judge deciding what sentence fits.
The same lobes are also among the first to decline with normal aging. Both ends of life are where frontal-lobe science tends to come up most in my cases.
Dr. Goldberg described a pattern that neuropsychologists have long called "pseudopsychopathic." Damage to the orbitofrontal region, the underside of the frontal lobes, can produce poor impulse control, emotional volatility, an inability to delay gratification, and general disinhibition. The person may be at real risk of antisocial behavior. The cause is often a traumatic brain injury, a stroke, or a degenerative disease.
He also drew a distinction I expect to use. Impulsive misconduct is linked to damage in the orbitofrontal cortex. Calculated deception, by contrast, depends on frontal regions that are working. That line is useful to the defense and to the State, and any lawyer raising a brain-based defense has to be ready for both sides of it.
The same act can come from a damaged brain or a working one. The science helps tell them apart.
The "pseudopsychopathic" syndrome. Often caused by TBI, stroke, or dementia such as FTD.
Deceptive behavior is linked to activation, not damage, of frontal areas.
The course materials on dementia were striking:
In a nationwide Finnish study, the first offense came an average of 2.7 years before anyone diagnosed the dementia.
64 of 171 patients with behavioral-variant FTD at UCSF had criminal behavior that first emerged during their illness.
The lesson for families is direct. When a person with no record is suddenly arrested in their 60s or 70s for shoplifting, a traffic offense, or an out-of-character outburst, the first question should not only be "what did they do?" It should also be "what is happening to their brain?"
Dr. Goldberg is known for challenging received wisdom, and he did so throughout the course. He was blunt that ADHD is often diagnosed casually, by people not qualified to make the call. He argued that some children labeled hyperactive have something else entirely, and that several conditions, including Tourette syndrome, are frequently misidentified.
He also drew a distinction that every trial lawyer should know. A disease is defined by its cause and usually has clear boundaries. A syndrome is a cluster of symptoms that tend to appear together, and its edges are often blurry. Many psychiatric and neurodevelopmental diagnoses are syndromes. As he put it, that makes diagnoses more subjective and arbitrary than most people assume.
One has a clear edge. The other shades into everything around it.
Defined by cause. Often discrete, with clear boundaries.
Defined by symptoms that tend to occur together. Dimensional, with blurry edges.
That cuts both ways in court. A diagnosis can open the door to mitigation, competency questions, or a defense. It can also be overstated, by either side. Testing tools have limits too, and standard intelligence tests may not measure executive function well at all. A client with a normal IQ score can still have serious frontal-lobe impairment. The defense needs an expert who understands those limits, and a lawyer who knows enough to test the State's expert on them.
This course was not my first time learning from Dr. Goldberg. I have retained him as a defense expert in two of my cases. In both, his evaluation gave the court and the prosecution something they had not seen before: a clear, science-based account of how my client's brain actually worked, and why that mattered to what happened. In both cases, his work helped us reach remarkable results for my clients.
What sets him apart as an expert is the same thing that sets him apart as a teacher. He explains complicated science in plain language, he does not overstate it, and he is willing to say when the conventional view is wrong. Judges and prosecutors notice that.
Every case is subject to its own facts and circumstances. Past results do not guarantee the same or a similar outcome in any other case.
If you are a family member reading this, a few practical points:
At Bark Law, I represent people charged with crimes in Seminole County, Orange County, Volusia County, and throughout Central Florida, with a particular focus on clients who are neurodivergent or living with brain injury, dementia, or other cognitive conditions. If someone you care about is facing charges and something about their behavior does not add up, call my office.
Call 407-865-8888